Guest Post: Katherine Fletcher – An Obvious Suspect Isn’t the Same as an Answer

November 12, 2026
S.F. Baumgartner

By S.F. Baumgartner

Katherine Fletcher is visiting today with a question for mystery readers: how quickly do you accept the obvious suspect? Here’s Katherine with a spoiler-free look at Lakeside Murder.

Lakeside Murder cover beside the words Suspicion Isn’t Evidence on a cream background.

By Katherine Fletcher

A public argument can be hard to forget. If one of the people involved later dies, that argument may be the first thing everyone remembers. But remembering a quarrel isn’t the same as knowing what happened afterward.

In Lakeside Murder, Craig Marsh argues with his brother Dennis over valuable lakefront property. Five days later, Craig is dead. Suspicion settles on Dennis, and the town has an explanation that seems easy to understand.

Dot Halstead isn’t satisfied.

What do we actually know?

Dot has known Dennis for thirty years. She doesn’t want Kettle Creek’s certainty to condemn him. That gives her a reason to keep asking questions, but familiarity alone can’t solve a case either.

The useful distinction is between a reason to suspect someone and evidence that tells you what they did. An argument matters. So do the records, the payments, and the details that don’t fit the convenient explanation.

Dot and her book-club friends follow those questions into the Historical Society’s affairs. The case involves questionable anniversary payments, contested land, and secrets in the town’s official history.

I’ll leave what they discover for the book.

A question to carry into your next mystery

When a story presents an obvious suspect, try asking yourself two things: what has actually been established, and what am I filling in because the explanation sounds convincing?

You don’t need a notebook or a list of rules. Just notice the difference between a fact and an assumption. You may keep your first theory, or you may find yourself changing it.

You can meet Dot and the Thursday Book Club on the Lakeside Murder book page. The novel is available now.

When you read a mystery, does the obvious suspect make you more confident in your guess, or immediately suspicious of it?

Leave the first comment