What Do You Jot Down While Reading a Mystery?

November 18, 2026
S.F. Baumgartner

By S.F. Baumgartner

Do you read a mystery with a notebook nearby, or trust yourself to remember everything? Either approach can work, right up until a busy week leaves you wondering which person owned the property and why that date mattered.

The Lost Claim by S.F. Baumgartner beside a notebook with sections labeled People, Facts, and Questions.

You don’t need an elaborate system to find your way back into a story. If notes help you, a few lines may be enough.

People

Write a name and one useful connection: the reporter, the neighbor, the person who handles the records. Keep the description brief. You’re making yourself a reminder, not compiling a complete character biography.

In The Lost Claim, the opening setup gives Lori Callahan and Noah Mercer different connections to the investigation. Lori understands mining records and discovers an alteration involving her father’s claim. Noah arrives with a receipt that connects that ground to his own family’s past.

Facts

Record what the story has actually established. If a detail seems important, add the chapter number so you can find it again without searching through the whole book.

A short note also helps separate something you read from something you guessed. “A date was altered” and “I think this person altered it” belong on different lines.

Questions

This is the place for possibilities. Why was a document kept? Who benefits if it disappears? What would you like the next conversation to explain?

You can change your mind as often as you like. There’s no score for keeping your first theory, and no need to turn every passing detail into a clue.

If note-taking pulls you out of the story, skip it. A bookmark and a quick glance at the previous chapter may be all you want.

For a mystery built around disputed records and disappearing evidence, you can meet Lori and Noah on The Lost Claim book page. It’s Book 2 of The Mercer Files and can be read as a standalone.

What helps you return to a mystery after a few days away?

Leave the first comment